“Premature optimization is the root of all evil” by Donald Knuth

One startup I worked with years ago failed because of the founder’s desire to perfect screen designs for the MVP.

He insisted on perfecting the user interface design so that the market would be impressed. No amount of warnings about speed vs perfection would help overcome this underlying belief that what gets released must be perfect.

After going through two designers and hundreds of hours of design, no MVP was launched. The startup failed and was dissolved.

What a shame to waste so much time, money, and opportunity.

He could not accept launching an MVP that would be anything but perfect.

During that period, a competitor launched. Their interface was not very amazing, however, they got to market. They were able to get customer feedback, gain market share, and progress as a company.

This is an example of the tradeoffs that startups must make every day between speed and optimization. In the tech world, this is what we refer to as “Technical Debt”. Pushing off optimization to another day, so we can achieve speed today. These tradeoff decisions get made about many things – not just development.

In this situation, incurring technical debt (imperfect design) would have been better so that they could have gotten to market and obtained market feedback. This would have helped them focus efforts on what should truly be optimized. Instead they failed and are out of business.

Trying to determine when to focus on speed vs optimization and when to start accruing technical debt, requires the right leadership – even from the CEO of the company.